Speak to a licensed agent and save up to $751 a year.

Do I Really Need Supplemental Insurance with Medicare?

Medicare supplemental insurance

Enrolling in Medicare is a big step. You’ve worked hard for many years, and you’ve paid into Medicare all that time. However, there comes a time when you will need Medicare, and you may be wondering if you truly need supplemental insurance if you already have Medicare.

Although the answer to this question varies from one person to another, one thing is clear. While Medicare covers a good portion of your medical costs, it does not cover everything. Medicare typically pays 80 percent of your medical expenses. The remaining 20 percent of the cost is left for you to pay.

Because this portion of your expenses is not covered, it is often essential to purchase Medigap or Medicare supplemental insurance. Medical procedures, especially surgeries, can cost tens of thousands of dollars that many seniors cannot afford to pay. That is why you need supplemental insurance, in addition to Medicare.

There may be cases where people have enough money and may not need to supplement their coverage. However, many seniors cannot afford to pay $100,000 or more for surgery. The cost of prescription drugs alone can be hard to afford. But why exactly do you need supplemental insurance if you have Medicare?

Because Medicare covers a portion of your medical costs, it may be beneficial to purchase supplemental coverage from a supplement insurance company. In addition to paying large amounts of money on medical procedures, you may also need to pay out-of-pocket for coinsurance, copayments, costly deductibles, and other expenses that you may not expect. 

Supplemental policies are purchased from private insurance companies and cover expenses that Medicare does not pay for. Also called Medigap, supplement insurance companies fill in the gaps in coverage, so you do not have to pay for expensive balances that could potentially drain your savings.

Most people on Medicare are above the age of 65 and are often on a fixed income. This can make it hard to afford extraneous medical expenses, in addition to other bills. Monthly premiums can vary significantly, and getting supplemental insurance can help cover the cost of future medical care and procedures. 

Despite Medigap’s many benefits, not everyone decides to get Medigap coverage. According to experts, most seniors have Medicare. Roughly 23 percent of seniors on Medicare have a Medigap policy. Roughly 30 percent of seniors have a Medicare Advantage Plan, experts say.

If you want to get a Medigap policy, it is important to sign up during your Medicare Supplement open enrollment period (OEP). The enrollment period begins when you are enrolled in Medicare Part B and when you reach the age of 65. 

The Medicare open enrollment period “lasts for six months.” This gives you ample time to pick a plan that meets your needs and fits your budget, while the policy is guarantee-issue with no health underwriting. The key to making the most of your Medigap policy is getting the right plan. You have a number of Medigap policies to choose from, and these policies help lower your out-of-pocket costs.

In addition to this, you get additional health care coverage. This is especially important to the aging population. Health conditions tend to develop in older age, and having supplemental coverage can ease the financial burden of costly treatments and procedures. Medicare supplement insurance plans are independent of the US government or Federal Medicare policies.

According to experts, Medigap is offered only to individuals who have Medicare Parts A and B. Medicare Parts A and B fall under the umbrella of Original Medicare. Medicare Part B covers preventative care and care that is necessary to one’s health, while Medicare Part A covers home health services, hospital care, hospice care, and care that is provided in nursing homes.

But can you change your care plan? There may be cases where you want to change your supplement insurance plan. Maybe your current plan has gotten too expensive, or your plan is not covering all the expenses you would like it to cover. Several other factors may make you want to change your plan. 

Poor customer service and services offered by your provider are all valid reasons to change your plan; however, it is often due to rate increases, especially if you got a supplemental plan to cover extra expenses. 

If you are already enrolled in a Medigap program, you can switch to a different policy at any point in time. By the time you decide to switch your Medicare Supplement plan, your OEP has likely passed.  By switching outside of your open enrollment period, you run the risk of not getting the exact coverage you want due to health underwriting. Health underwriting does not involve a doctor visit and is often a quick questionnaire over the telephone regarding your current and historical health. 

What are the benefits of having supplemental insurance with Medicare? Medicare supplement insurance plans are beneficial in many ways. These plans provide an extra level of coverage that Original Medicare does not. A supplemental insurance may be beneficial if you are traveling outside of your state to receive treatment or care. This is especially important if you are a snowbird. 

A supplemental policy may also benefit you if you wish to see a specific doctor that is approved by Medicare. You may see any doctor that participates in original Medicare, unlike an advantage plan; that network is ~800,000 doctors nationwide. A supplemental plan can also help if you need help paying costs not covered by Original Medicare. 

What about cost? How are costs affected when you have a supplemental insurance policy? According to experts, most people pay nothing for Medicare Part A. The amount you pay for supplemental policies in 2023 depends on your location, the type of Medigap policy you buy, and several other factors including your age, gender and tobacco use. 

If you want to obtain and keep a Medigap policy, you must have Medicare Part B, and you must pay your Part B premium. The cost you pay for a supplemental policy will ultimately depend upon the type of policy you purchase. Some supplemental policies offer perks that lower costs, such as health care coverage for international travel. 

Those who are new to Medicare often don’t realize that Original Medicare does not cover all your medical expenses. There are many supplemental insurance policies. Medigap plans offered by private insurance companies are “designated” by the letters A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M, and N, experts say. Benefits are standardized across all policies, and each plan must offer the same benefits.

As of January 1, 2020, new enrollers can no longer purchase coverage under Plans C and F – the only 2 plans that cover the Part B deductible. However, those who were already enrolled in Plans C and F were able to keep this coverage and receive the benefits they offer. 

There are several reasons to get a Medigap policy. Having a Medigap plan can eliminate out-of-pocket costs associated with Medicare Parts A and B. Because a Medigap policy covers the amount you are responsible for paying, seniors are able to live more comfortably and not stress about extraneous medical costs.

Additionally, Medigap is beneficial for those who require skilled nursing facility care, according to Fidelity. Although Medigap does not offer long-term care (LTC) insurance, some shorter term SNK stays qualify for coverage. This includes coverage for hospital stays. If you are traveling overseas, your lifetime coverage is $50,000. 

If you would like more coverage, you can purchase travel insurance. Travel insurance covers medical evacuations for emergencies if you are traveling abroad. The cost of travel insurance will depend on where you are traveling, how long you will travel, and your age. Another plus of a supplemental policy is the fact that you can keep your doctor without being constricted to a network. Medicare Supplement plans are neither an HMO nor a PPO, and you may see any doctor in the country that accepts original Medicare – 93% of all physicians in the U.S. 

With Medicare Advantage, an alternative to a Medigap plan, you must make sure that your doctor, specialist, or medical facility accepts your specific policy. Medigap policies offer a number of benefits that other policies do not. These policies cover your Part A deductible, Part B excess charges, and a Part B copayment or coinsurance.

In addition, Medigap covers your Part B deductible and pays for the first three pints of blood. It will also cover hospital costs and coinsurance for up to one year after all Medicare benefits are used up. Now that you know that you need supplemental insurance, you may be wondering how much you need. When deciding how much coverage to purchase, you need to consider the status of your health and your age. Someone who is 85 may require more or less coverage than someone who is 65 or 75. It may also help to look into the history of your family to find out what health issues run in your family. However, you have only one guarantee issue window during your OEP to enroll in a plan, so we recommend selecting the plan at 65 you plan to stick with. 

This will help you plan for any conditions that may arise. However, by having supplemental coverage, you are better equipped to handle health issues in the future. You may also want to compare the costs of coverage and make a decision that is best for you. If you find that a Medigap policy is not the best option for you, there are other options that can help cover medical costs as you age.

9 Sources

MedigapCoverage has strict sourcing guidelines to ensure our content is accurate and current. We rely on peer-reviewed studies, academic research institutions, and medical associations. We strive to use primary sources and refrain from using tertiary references.

https://www.westernsouthern.com/retirement/do-i-need-supplemental-insurance-if-i-have-medicare

Medicare Supplement Insurance | Medigap Insurance (westernsouthern.com)

https://clearmatchmedicare.com/blog/medicare/disadvantages-of-medigap-plans

https://ncoa.org/article/what-is-medigap

https://www.blueshieldca.com/bsca/bsc/wcm/connect/sites/Sites_Content_EN/medicare/learn-about-medicare/medicaretopics/medicare-article-cards/why_choose_a_medicare_supplement_plan

https://www.medicare.gov/basics/costs/medicare-costs

https://www.fidelity.com/viewpoints/retirement/medigap-what-you-need-to-know

https://www.aarp.org/health/medicare-insurance/info-2020/what-is-medicare.html

https://www.bcbs.com/medicare/medigap

Still confused? Call us!

We’re here at 833-245-0614 to answer any questions, and ready to help with any issues you might have with an insurer through the enrollment process.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Table of Contents

FAQs

  • Best overall Medicare supplement for new enrollees: Plan G.
  • Best overall Medicare supplement before 2020: Plan F.
  • Best low cost Medicare supplement: Plan K.
  • Best alternative to Plan G Medicare supplement: Plan N.

Learn More

Medicare Supplement policies are private health insurance designed to cover gaps in Original Medicare. They are also known as Medigap plans. These take care of costs such as copays, coinsurance, and deductibles which can become expensive if you need regular care from a doctor or hospital. If you need medical care while traveling outside the U.S., you can buy Medigap policies to help cover those costs. As a supplement to Original Medicare, you’re required to have Part A and Part B before you canget a Medigap policy. This way, Medicare is responsible for the Medicare-approved costs of the covered care, and the remainder is covered by your Medigap plan.

Learn More

Optimal coverage comes with higher costs, making Plan F the most expensive Medigap plan. Plan F is known as “first-dollar coverage” and it takes care of everything provided during a doctor or hospital visit. Your only responsibility is for dental, vision, medications, and equipment, such as hearing aids.

Learn More

The Federal government ended the Plan F option for new enrollees last year to keep the healthcare system from being overused by patients who had their deductibles covered. The next best coverage after Plan F is Plan G.

Learn More

Medigap Plan G offers every advantage of Plan F except for the deductible, which you have to cover. Because it isn’t as comprehensive as Plan F, Plan G is more affordable.

Learn More

For people who don’t go to the doctor often, Plan K is worth considering. It is the most affordable because it provides just 50% of Medicare Part B coinsurance, the Part A deductible, blood, skilled nursing, and Part A hospice costs. For comparison, Plan G and others offer full coverage of these expenses, and more.

Learn More

It’s hard to argue against plans which cut your traditional Medicare costs. For most people, having the extra coverage these supplemental plans provide is common sense, unless they want the specific features of a Medicare Advantage plan.

Learn More

Most people would benefit from not having to pay out-of-pocket to stay healthy. Medicare supplement insurance or a Medicare Advantage plan offer vital savings now, but are indispensable should a catastrophic health issue occur.

Learn More

Of the 10 Medicare-approved Medigap plans, Plan G and Plan N are the most popular. Plan F is no longer available to new Medicare enrollees as of 2020, but it is still popular among people who bought this plan prior to 2020.

Learn More

  • Plan F$128–$342
  • Plan F (high deductible)$22–$88
  • Plan G$106–$325
  • Plan G (high deductible)$29–$58

Learn More

Before getting a Medicare supplement plan, you need to be enrolled in Medicare Part A (hospital insurance) and Part B (medical insurance). People with Medicare Advantage Plans who want to go back to Original Medicare can buy a Medigap policy prior to switching.

Learn More

The security of having lower or no out-of-pocket healthcare costs can offset the premiums you’ll have to pay for whichever Medigap plan you choose, which vary depending on the benefits offered.

Learn More

The national average cost for Medicare Supplement Plan F is $1,824 annually, which is $152/month; Medigap Plan G will cost you around $143 per month.

Learn More

Since Plan F was discontinued for new enrollees as of 2020, Plan G offers the most coverage for people 65 and older. It has a lower premium than Plan F and duplicates its benefits, except for the Part B deductible.

Learn More

It depends on your specific needs, but for most people a Medigap plan is very useful in supplementing the coverage of Medicare Part A and Part B. A Medicare Advantage plan is an affordable way to get healthcare coverage not offered by Original Medicare.

Historically, Plan F has been the most popular because it covers all the out-of-pocket costs Medicare does’t pay for. This includes the 15% extra charge billed by providers who do not take Medicare as full payment.

Learn More

Since January 1, 2006, no Medigap policy came with prescription drug coverage. You have two options to get covered, enrolling in either a Medicare Prescription Drug Plan (Part D) or a Medicare Advantage plan.

Learn More

Have a Question? We've Got You Covered.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.